Aletho News


FBI adds to no-fly list Muslims who refuse to spy on their communities

Voice of Russia | April 23, 2014

A lawsuit, filed on behalf of four different men, blames the United States of violating their rights by keeping them on the no-fly list after they declined to spy on local Muslim communities, notably in New York, New Jersey and Nebraska. Some view the move as a punishment, though more likely this is a rigid coercive tool, plaintiffs argue.

“The no-fly list is supposed to be about ensuring aviation safety, but the FBI is using it to force innocent people to become informants,” said Ramzi Kassem, associate professor of law at the City University of New York, adding the practice looks more like an extortion.

The four plaintiffs have different stories to tell, however sharing one common feature: all the four point to US authorities over-policing the local Muslim society.

Awais Sajjad, for instance, a Muslim, lawfully naturalized US resident living in the New York area learnt he was on the no-fly list after he was turned back at the boarding zone at John F. Kennedy International Airport.

At the airport, FBI agents questioned Sajjad, a Muslim, before he was finally released. But later returned with an offer. In exchange for working for them, the FBI could provide him with US citizenship and compensation. To score a deal, the agents reminded Sajjad, it was up to the FBI to decide who was on the no-fly list.

“The more you help us, the more we can help you,” FBI agents said, according to the lawsuit filed Tuesday.

Another plaintiff, Naveed Shinwari, hasn’t seen his wife in more than two years, ever since they got married, he living permanently in the US, while his wife being an Afghan citizen. He strongly suspects it’s due to his refusal to become an informant for the FBI.

Returning back from the wedding, before he could even get home to Omaha, Nebraska, he was twice detained and questioned by FBI agents. These, he recollects, asked if he knew anything about national security threats. A third FBI visit followed when he got home, with the officer wanting to know about the “local Omaha community”, if he knew “anyone who’s a threat.”

Next time he was denied a boarding pass on a domestic US flight as he was to embark on a temporary job in Connecticut. Police told him he had been placed on the US no-fly list, although he had never in his life been accused of breaking any law.

Two more stories slightly varied from the previous ones, in that they contain a certain straight-forward directive, in line with the Muslims’ belief that law enforcement at times considers them a target, particularly thanks to mosque infiltrations and other surveillance practices.

Jameel Algibhah of the Bronx alleges that the FBI explicitly asked him to infiltrate a Queens mosque and pose as an extremist in online forums.

Their case follows at least one other, brought by the ACLU in Oregon, according to which the FBI attempted to leverage no-fly selectees into informants. Most sadly, the agency that’s behind the practice ever since no-fly lists emerged, is uniquely responsible for taking names off them. What all the four Muslims, who have never been convicted of a crime seek for, is to be cleared of the unjust punitive measures.

The FBI refused to comment Tuesday. But the process used to place individuals on the no-fly list has always been considered legal and well founded by officials, who said the practice relies on credible intelligence. Notably, MI5 in Britain openly thanked those Muslims who contributed to spying on others.

April 23, 2014 - Posted by | Civil Liberties, Islamophobia | ,

1 Comment »

  1. If I understand this correctly, and please do correct me if I am wrong, these four men, individuals, are punished and criminalized by the United States of America, in casu the Federal Bureaux of Investigation (aka FBI) for deciding not to become criminals!?

    How I understand it, is that these four men were asked to become spies of their own communities, without there being any substantial evidence by the FBI, the authorities, of any criminal act by or through these communities, and that thee four men refused to become traitors of their communities, and that following that refusal the authorities decided to punish these four men by putting them on a list of dangerous individuals, and preventing them from traveling by air.

    Were I come from, these sort practices wereby authorities and or representatives of the authorities to try convincing individuals to cooperate with the authorities is considered illegal and unlawful!

    Every cooperation with the authorities by civilians should be freely and without coercion, and without any activity when and if the civilian does not want to cooperate with the authority demanding the cooperation, and every action to punish the civilian for not choosing to cooperate with the authorities is to be considered illegal, and regarded as unlawful!

    No civilian should be punished for refusing to spy on, and betray other civilians when and if those other civilians have not committed a crime!

    In my opinion, if the authorities are not able to trace and track criminal activities by anyone, or any community, they fail in their efforts to safeguard the safety of the civilians, subjecting members of that community to coercion to participate in official activities to trace and or track possible criminal activities is, in my opinion, sick, foul, criminal, illegal and unlawful!

    By pressuring civilians to cooperate with authorities on and in matters were no criminal activity has occurred, or no criminal act has committed, to spy and possibly fabricate false evidence to adhere to the demand of the authorities is, in my opinion, sicker then the possible crime committed!
    Such pressure is, in my opinion, reason for criminal prosecution of those who did put the pressure on these individuals!

    My opinion!


    Comment by masteradrian | April 23, 2014 | Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.