Aletho News


Is Trump Enlisting in the War Party?

By Pat Buchanan • Unz Review • April 11, 2017

By firing off five dozen Tomahawk missiles at a military airfield, our “America First” president may have plunged us into another Middle East war that his countrymen do not want to fight.

Thus far Bashar Assad seems unintimidated. Brushing off the strikes, he has defiantly gone back to bombing the rebels from the same Shayrat air base that the U.S. missiles hit.

Trump “will not stop here,” warned U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley on Sunday. “If he needs to do more, he will.”

If Trump fails to back up Haley’s threat, the hawks now cheering him on will begin deriding him as “Donald Obama.”

But if he throbs to the war drums of John McCain, Lindsey Graham and Marco Rubio and orders Syria’s air force destroyed, we could be at war not only with ISIS and al-Qaida, but with Syria, Russia, Iran and Hezbollah.

A Syrian war would consume Trump’s presidency.

Are we ready for that? How would we win such a war without raising a large army and sending it back into the Middle East?

Another problem: Trump’s missile attack was unconstitutional. Assad had not attacked or threatened us, and Congress, which alone has the power to authorize war on Syria, has never done so.

Indeed, Congress denied President Obama that specific authority in 2013.

What was Trump thinking? Here was his strategic rational:

“When you kill innocent children, innocent babies — babies, little babies — with a chemical gas … that crosses many, many lines, beyond a red line. … And I will tell you, that attack on children yesterday had a big impact on me … my attitude toward Syria and Assad has changed very much.”

Two days later, Trump was still emoting: “Beautiful babies were cruelly murdered in this very barbaric attack. No child of God should ever suffer such horror.”

Now, that gas attack was an atrocity, a war crime, and pictures of its tiny victims are heart-rending. But 400,000 people have died in Syria’s civil war, among them thousands of children and infants.

Have they been killed by Assad’s forces? Surely, but also by U.S., Russian, Israeli and Turkish planes and drones — and by Kurds, Iranians, Hezbollah, al-Qaida, ISIS, U.S.-backed rebels and Shiite militia.

Assad is battling insurgents and jihadists who would slaughter his Alawite brethren and the Christians in Syria just as those Copts were massacred in Egypt on Palm Sunday. Why is Assad more responsible for all the deaths in Syria than those fighting to overthrow and kill him?

Are we certain Assad personally ordered a gas attack on civilians?

For it makes no sense. Why would Assad, who is winning the war and had been told America was no longer demanding his removal, order a nerve gas attack on children, certain to ignite America’s rage, for no military gain?

Like the gas attack in 2013, this has the marks of a false flag operation to stampede America into Syria’s civil war.

And as in most wars, the first shots fired receive the loudest cheers. But if the president has thrown in with the neocons and War Party, and we are plunging back into the Mideast maelstrom, Trump should know that many of those who helped to nominate and elect him — to keep us out of unnecessary wars — may not be standing by him.

We have no vital national interest in Syria’s civil war. It is those doing the fighting who have causes they deem worth dying for.

For ISIS, it is the dream of a caliphate. For al-Qaida, it is about driving the Crusaders out of the Dar al Islam. For the Turks, it is, as always, about the Kurds.

For Assad, this war is about his survival and that of his regime. For Putin, it is about Russia remaining a great power and not losing its last naval base in the Med. For Iran, this is about preserving a land bridge to its Shiite ally Hezbollah. For Hezbollah it is about not being cut off from the Shiite world and isolated in Lebanon.

Because all have vital interests in Syria, all have invested more blood in this conflict than have we. And they are not going to give up their gains or goals in Syria and yield to the Americans without a fight.

And if we go to war in Syria, what would we be fighting for?

A New World Order? Democracy? Separation of mosque and state? Diversity? Free speech for Muslim heretics? LGBT rights?

In 2013, a great national coalition came together to compel Congress to deny Barack Obama authority to take us to war in Syria.

We are back at that barricade. An after-Easter battle is shaping up in Congress on the same issue: Is the president authorized to take us into war against Assad and his allies inside Syria?

If, after Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya and Yemen, we do not want America in yet another Mideast war, the time to stop it is before the War Party has us already in it. That time is now.

Copyright 2017

April 11, 2017 - Posted by | Militarism, Timeless or most popular | , , , , , ,


  1. Fuck Haley. Someone else, please; I’m not interested.

    I generally admire Pat Buchanan’s take on geopolitical affairs, and I do so unreservedly here. (Item: Pat could have delved into the psychotic Zionist machinations that underlie every action we contemplate or take in the Middle East…and beyond.)


    Comment by roberthstiver | April 11, 2017 | Reply

  2. My comment seems to have disappeared Mr Aletho – but the site insists it is a duplicate post if I try to post it again …. :-(


    Comment by redracam | April 11, 2017 | Reply

    • Is size an issue? It was long …


      Comment by redracam | April 11, 2017 | Reply

      • I don’t know.

        Try altering it slightly or breaking into two comments.


        Comment by aletho | April 11, 2017 | Reply

  3. Original post cut up …
    Even easier, roberthstiver, he could stop using those little touchstone epithets that are there just to placate the MSM line and sound “reasonable” in the light of their logic (propaganda).
    And, yes, I too admire Pat Buchanan but that doesn’t excuse his tightrope walking on such serious issues.


    Comment by redracam | April 11, 2017 | Reply

  4. part 2
    “For Assad, this war is about his survival and that of his regime” – he has already faced two presidential elections under the new constitution that he ushered in.
    “Why is Assad more responsible for all the deaths in Syria than those fighting to overthrow and kill him?” – They are not fighting to overthrow Bashar al-Assad they are fighting to put into power a Western stooge who will serve Washington. (Subtle difference)


    Comment by redracam | April 11, 2017 | Reply

  5. part 3
    “Assad is battling insurgents and jihadists who would slaughter his Alawite brethren[..]” – His wife is Sunni, brought up in Acton UK so are they his “brethren” too – English from Acton and Sunnis or just Sunnis from Acton, UK?
    “Now, that gas attack was an atrocity, a war crime, and pictures of its tiny victims are heart-rending” – where is the evidence for a gas attack outside the “White Helmet” propaganda (organisation set up and abetted by MI6). Anybody who saw the analysis done by Mother Agnès-Mariam de la Croix, abbess of the convent St. Jean le Mutilé in Qara on the al-Ghoutta chemical attack in 2013 will know what to expect when clarity is shone on this attack. She pointed out that in videos purportedly representing different scenes of atrocity the same children wearing the same clothes could be seen.


    Comment by redracam | April 11, 2017 | Reply

  6. part 4
    This is not to say that children have not died. However, there is a better than 50% chance that the white helmets brought the children from somewhere else and staged “their intervention”. Too sick to contemplate …

    As for those such as Colin Powell and Nikki Haley “Crucify!” should be our cry not what you said roberthstiver – too much ambiguity (and you don’t know what you would catch).


    Comment by redracam | April 11, 2017 | Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.