Aletho News


Naomi Klein: Gatekeeper Extraordinaire

Veteran journalist lines up alongside the mainstream, attacking “conspiracy theorists” and “covid denialism”.

By Cat Maguire & Colleen Maguire | OffGuardian | December 11, 2020

With a title like The Great Reset Conspiracy Smoothie, it appears Naomi Klein is trying too hard to recapture her prowess at defining a meme. Her buzz-concept, “Shock Doctrine,” is spot-on and rightfully successful. But her “Screen New Deal” about Silicon Valley technocrats fizzled.

And now she puts forth “Conspiracy Smoothie,” declaring the multitudinous “conspiracies” out there are just one big bizarro mashup, an “inchoate meta-scream.” The word “smoothie” defeats her purpose, though, because smoothies are healthy, yet she wants to brand alternative thinkers as sinister and unhealthy. Ha! This feckless meme won’t catch on with anybody.

To her credit, Klein offers a very good history and analysis of The Great Reset, as long as she stays within the precincts of critiquing Empire, such as:

… [T]he Great Reset is not a serious effort to actually solve the crises it describes. On the contrary, it is an attempt to create a plausible impression that the huge winners in this system are on the verge of voluntarily setting greed aside to get serious about solving the raging crises that are radically destabilizing our world.

But once she gets near taboo topics, Naomi goes batshit mainstream. Unlike alt “researchers” (her raised-eyebrow quotes), these subjects are “inchoate” for her because, like NIST who doesn’t know there were explosives on 9/11, she hasn’t gone looking. She even admits, “I’ve been doing my best to ignore it [“conspiracies”] for months.”

Rather than go off-reservation and investigate for herself, like a typical conspiracy denier, everything under the hood is automatically deemed “off-the-wall.” Alison McDowall will surely skewer Klein again as seen during this prickly exchange they had about The Great Reset. (See video at 13:25 to 17:00)

Klein’s most damning accusation is her reference to “truly dangerous anti-vaccination fantasies and outright coronavirus denialism.” Is Klein really this naive about the objectives and tactics of the Medical Industrial Complex?

Her anti-vaxx slur is a defamation against vaccine-activists, most of whom actually advocate for safe and effective vaccines — the existence of which, however, are questionable. Vaccine manufacturers have no incentive to make a safe product because they were granted legal immunity in 1986 by Congress.

Proof there exists a serious safety deficit in vaccines is the current running tab of $4.2 billion awarded to victims and their families in “Vaccine Court” from vaccine deaths and injuries.

Klein’s political bifurcation of conspiracy theories telegraphs an utter misreading of allies and issues:

And yet search for the term “global reset” and you will be bombarded with breathless “exposés” of a secret globalist cabal, headed by Schwab and Bill Gates, that is using the state of shock created by the coronavirus (which is probably itself a “hoax”) to turn the world into a high-tech dictatorship that will take away your freedom forever: a green/socialist/Venezuela/Soros/forced vaccine dictatorship if the Reset exposé is coming from the far right, and a Big Pharma/GMO/biometric implants/5G/robot dog/forced vaccine dictatorship if the exposé hails from the far left.

After channeling Cass Sunstein in the above paragraph, she asks readers if they are confused. No, Naomi, you are the one who is confused. You are the one who cannot recognize that most of these issues are not only scientifically legitimate, but many are important to and shared by global activists and professionals across the political spectrum. You are the one who is out of touch for not recognizing how and why these issues unite many diverse communities. Unlike the binary tribalism you attribute to the above players, their unity is transpartisan.

In Klein’s inventory of 2020 shock doctrines, it’s all the fault of the right side of the aisle. There is not an ounce of finger-pointing, for example, that the extreme failures of the lockdowns are almost wholly the result of diktats by petty Democratic tyrants (not to mention their over-the-top hypocrisy).

Shockingly, she fails to comment on the source of the epic silencing of anyone who questions Official Narratives. To wit, Big Tech and Big Media censors are fully aligned with Democratic agendas. As for the Left’s political-identity swamp, there is nary a mention of Mao’s Cultural Revolution USA-style that has ravaged our country.

The World According to Naomi is full of plutocrats, but they’re all right-wing. She goes on and on about workers rights and all the populist issues that Democrats traditionally stood for. Didn’t she get the memo that there’s been a tectonic shift? Doesn’t she realize that the entire force of the 1% has arrayed itself with the Democrats, a party that has now disgracefully abandoned what had been their deplorables base for decades.

If Bernie progressives, we-the-people patriots, the Yellow Vests, indigenous peoples, and all the rest of the world’s 99% would just join hands, we could create a powerful transpartisan movement to abort The Great Reset’s dystopian agenda. But this can’t happen by staying within the Democrats’ Big Tent as Klein does, which likewise ultimately aligns her with the Establishment no matter how much she critiques them from her influential, mainstream-left perch.

Invoking an ever-reliable inference to Trump Derangement Syndrome, she writes:

Is it all a plan, another kind of elaborate conspiracy? Nothing so elegant. As Steve Bannon kindly told us, the informational strategy of the Trump era has always been to “flood the zone with shit.” Four years later, we can see what this looks like in practice. It looks like far-left and far-right conspiracists sitting down over a tray of information-shit sandwiches to talk about how the Great Reset is Gates’s plan to use the DNA from our Covid-19 tests to turn the United States into Venezuela.

“It makes no sense,” she concludes. Yep, Naomi, if you don’t investigate beyond ad hominem analysis and if you seemingly strive for a token social-responsibility seat at the Davos table, your current worldview will only ever perceive genuine opposition to The Great Reset as an indigestible smoothie.

Cat McGuire and Colleen McGuire are twin sisters who are activists and writers. Cat lives in New York City where she works with Break The Spell, a public outreach group raising awareness about the Covid plandemic and the Great Reset. Colleen practiced law in New York City for 16 years and now lives in Greece.

December 10, 2020 - Posted by | Progressive Hypocrite, Timeless or most popular |


  1. Noted. Naomi Klein is one of my most-admired investigative journalists. If she has wandered here, who will undertake to expose her, identify her, force the “mainstream” media (US media, not UK…) to give her wanderlust attention, and go forward from there?

    Liked by 1 person

    Comment by roberthstiver | December 11, 2020 | Reply

  2. She is a Jew. What is the promise of the Jew religion to the Jew people? Why haven’t they ever told us? Is it a conspiracy theory to wonder why? Every religion offers a benefit to its adherents as a means to draw people to the religion, it is the nature of all religions. So what benefit does Judaism offer Jews? Anybody?

    What does chosen mean, as in Gods chosen people, if not to hold dominion over the non-Jew?
    What does it mean??

    The Jews are conspiring against us to enslave us. No theory, that is a fact.


    Comment by Robert Browning | December 11, 2020 | Reply

    • “She is Jew”….Well, like everybody else on this planet, there are “Good” and “Bad” Jews.

      “Every Religion offers a benefit to its adherents”…….. “Benefits” which are entirely illogical, and utterly unverifiable. NOBODY can guarantee anything, about what happens to us, when we die……It is the ultimate ‘Con Job’, motivated in individuals by FEAR of the unknown.

      Liked by 1 person

      Comment by brianharryaustralia | December 11, 2020 | Reply

      • “Like”! — still can’t get this system to work for me…inefficient.

        Liked by 1 person

        Comment by roberthstiver | December 11, 2020 | Reply

        • Cant get used to this system”?….Didn’t you recently purchase a different computer? Is it an “APPLE”?

          Liked by 1 person

          Comment by brianharryaustralia | December 11, 2020 | Reply

          • Thanks for youe


            Comment by roberthstiver | December 11, 2020 | Reply

          • (Prior comment got sent prematurely after typing/mistyping “Thanks for youe”….)
            Brian, thanks for your questions. I do indeed have an Apple plus this Mac — use both interchangeably. Most often, I click “Like” and nothing happens. Other times (e.g., just now), I click on your comment(s) and the “Liked by you” appears. A couple of months ago and for years prior, my “Like” click would be recorded automatically and instantly. Perhaps I’m just impatient and must wait for second(s) for my “Like” command to be recognized. I’ll keep trying…. But I must say that the frustration level has markedly reduced my consumption of Aletho News releases (it’s not just the “Like” function; I must now fill in laborious prompts in order for a comment by me to be “posted”). Here, though, since it’s not my first comment to this post, it seems that I won’t have to go through that “laborious prompts” routine.

            Liked by 1 person

            Comment by roberthstiver | December 11, 2020 | Reply

            • It may be that you now have cookies being auto-deleted on a regular basis.


              Comment by aletho | December 11, 2020 | Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.