Aletho News


Surprise! The Supreme Court Defers to the CIA

By Jacob G. Hornberger | FFF | March 4, 2022

As longtime readers of my blog know, I have long maintained that it is the national-security branch of the federal government that runs the government, especially when it comes to foreign affairs. The other three branches, while being permitted to have the veneer of running the government, actually operate in support of the national-security branch. 

This is also the thesis set forth in a book that I have long recommended, entitled National Security and Double Government by Michael J. Glennon, professor of law at Tufts University.

Yesterday, the U.S. Supreme Court’s ruling in a case involving the CIA provides a perfect example of this phenomenon. 

The case involved a man named Abu Zubaydah, who the CIA accused of being a terrorist as part of its much-vaunted worldwide “war on terrorism.” After taking Zubaydah captive some 20 years ago, the CIA subjected him to brutal torture, including 80 hours of waterboarding, hundreds of hours of live burial, and “rectal rehydration.” It should be pointed out that U.S. officials have never convicted Zubaydah of a crime.

Zubaydah was tortured at CIA “black sites,” such as one that the CIA operated in Poland, one of the former Warsaw Pact countries that was absorbed by NATO. Later, he was transferred to the Pentagon’s and the CIA’s torture and prison center at Guantanamo Bay.

The reason that Zubaydah was tortured was that CIA and Pentagon officials were convinced that he was a high-ranking figure in al Qaeda, which the CIA later concluded was a mistake. Nonetheless, Zubaydah remains incarcerated at Gitmo, where for 20 years the CIA and the Pentagon steadfastly failed to grant him a speedy trial, a right guaranteed in the Bill of Rights.

Zubaydah filed a legal action seeking to take depositions of two private-sector individuals who served as torturers for the CIA. He wanted them to testify under oath as to everything they did to him. 

The CIA objected, arguing that Zubadah’s legal action should be dismissed on two grounds: (1) The depositions of the two torturers would inevitably reveal the fact that the CIA maintained a black site in Poland, which, the CIA maintains, falls within the state-secrets doctrine that the Supreme Court, in another act of extreme deference, awarded the CIA decades ago; and (2) It would breach a promise that the CIA entered into with Poland to keep their joint dark-side activities secret.

Not surprisingly, the Supreme Court, in a 7-2 decision, deferred to the CIA and dismissed Zubaydah’s lawsuit. The Court held that “national security” dictated that the CIA would be permitted to keep secret the location of its black sites and the details of its dark-side activities, including torture. It’s just tough luck for victims of CIA and Pentagon torture, kidnapping, rendition, indefinite detention, assassination, and other totalitarian-like dark-side activity. 

Needless to say, if a similar legal action were to be brought in Russia, China, or North Korea — all of which also have national-security state forms of government — the judicial ruling would be the same. In every national-security state, most everyone within the government pays extreme deference to the military-intelligence part of the government and gives them free rein to do whatever they want to people. 

March 5, 2022 - Posted by | Subjugation - Torture, Timeless or most popular | , ,


  1. All these national-security states might think they are immune, and can get away with anything they want, but there is a judgment coming in which all the operatives will be held responsible and accountable for all their crimes. God is not mocked!

    Liked by 1 person

    Comment by Bill Francis | March 5, 2022 | Reply

  2. Noted; kudos for JGH’s reporting and AN’s post. Read about, and was disgusted by, this yesterday/3-4th. My essential reply to my e-correspondent was “Put paid to the CIA…at long last already and good riddance!”

    SCOTUS is (another) sick, demented joke. “The first thing we do is kill all the lawyers.” (thanks, Shakespeare) [kill ’em after 20 years of various forms of extremely uncomfortable torture]

    Liked by 1 person

    Comment by roberthstiver | March 5, 2022 | Reply

  3. I don’t think there is any doubt about where the REAL POWER in the USA is. It is certainly NOT in the White House or the Congress. The CIA have been acting independently from, and completely unaccountable to, the ‘bought and paid for’ politicians, who have grown Fat and extremely rich over the past 50 years that I am aware of.
    What other country on Earth would “9/11” have happened and then, be “brushed under the carpet’ by its own politicians? And just have a look at the “idiot Ratbag” Presidents that the USA has had in the past 60 years
    LBJ, “Dumb Jerry” Ford, Nixon, “Brain dead Ronny Reagan” GHW Bush, Dubya Bush, Trump, and now poor old Joe Leiberman………”Politicians are just the Entertainment division of the Military Industrial Complex”….Frank Zappa.

    The CIA, who claim to be keeping Americans safe, have trampled on them instead, and deal with “America’s Enemies” in Gulags in Poland, Gitmo Cuba etc, OUTSIDE of the American Legal system. The CIA are accountable to NO ONE…….
    And, you call it, “Freedom and Democracy”……???

    Liked by 1 person

    Comment by brianharryaustralia | March 5, 2022 | Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.