Aletho News


Creator Of Global-Warming’s Infamous “Hockey Stick” Chart Loses ‘Climate-Science’ Lawsuit

By Tyler Durden – Zero Hedge – 08/27/2019

Update 1: Michael Mann disputes the notion that he lost (and more): “There have been some wildly untruthful claims about the recent dismissal of libel litigation against Tim Ball circulating on social media.”

*  *  *

Update has a rather different take than Mann, noting that further legal steps are on their way.

Penn State climate scientist, Michael ‘hockey stick’ Mann commits contempt of court in the ‘climate science trial of the century.’ Prominent alarmist shockingly defies judge and refuses to surrender data for open court examination. Only possible outcome: Mann’s humiliation, defeat and likely criminal investigation in the U.S.

The defendant in the libel trial, the 79-year-old Canadian climatologist, Dr Tim Ball … is expected to instruct his British Columbia attorneys to trigger mandatory punitive court sanctions, including a ruling that Mann did act with criminal intent when using public funds to commit climate data fraud. Mann’s imminent defeat is set to send shock waves worldwide within the climate science community as the outcome will be both a legal and scientific vindication of U.S. President Donald Trump’s claims that climate scare stories are a “hoax.” (snip)

Michael Mann, who chose to file what many consider to be a cynical SLAPP (Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation) libel suit in the British Columbia Supreme Court, Vancouver six long years ago, has astonished legal experts by refusing to comply with the court direction to hand over all his disputed graph’s data. Mann’s iconic hockey stick has been relied upon by the UN’s IPCC and western governments as crucial evidence for the science of ‘man-made global warming.’ (snip)

The negative and unresponsive actions of Dr Mann and his lawyer, Roger McConchie, are expected to infuriate the judge and be the signal for the collapse of Mann’s multi-million dollar libel suit against Dr Ball. It will be music to the ears of so-called ‘climate deniers’ like President Donald Trump and his EPA Chief, Scott Pruitt.

As Dr Ball explains:

“Michael Mann moved for an adjournment of the trial scheduled for February 20, 2017. We had little choice because Canadian courts always grant adjournments before a trial in their belief that an out of court settlement is preferable. We agreed to an adjournment with conditions. The major one was that he [Mann] produce all documents including computer codes by February 20th, 2017. He failed to meet the deadline.”

Punishment for Civil Contempt

Mann’s now proven contempt of court means Ball is entitled to have the court serve upon Mann the fullest punishment. Contempt sanctions could reasonably include the judge ruling that Dr. Ball’s statement that Mann “belongs in the state pen, not Penn. State’ is a precise and true statement of fact. This is because under Canada’s unique ‘Truth Defense’, Mann is now proven to have wilfully hidden his data, so the court may rule he hid it because it is fake. As such, the court must then dismiss Mann’s entire libel suit with costs awarded to Ball and his team.

*  *  *

Authored by Thomas Lifson via AmericanThinker,

Michael Mann, a climatologist at Penn State University, is the creator of the “hockey stick graph” that appears to show global temperatures taking a noticeable swing upward in the era when humanity has been burning fossil fuels and dumping CO2 into the atmosphere.

The graph was first published in 1998, prominently featured in the 2001 UN Climate Report, and formed part of Al Gore’s 2006 movie, An Inconvenient Truth.

The graph’s methodology and accuracy have been and continue to be hotly contested, but Mann has taken the tack of suing two of his most prominent critics for defamation or libel.

One case, against Mark Steyn, is called by Steyn likely to end up in the Supreme Court. But another case, against Dr. Tim Ball was decided by the Supreme Court of British Columbia, with Mann’s case thrown out, and him ordered to pay the defendant’s legal costs, no doubt a tidy sum of money. News first broke in Wattsupwiththat, via an email Ball sent to Anthony Watt. Later, Principia-Scientific offered extensive details, including much background on the hockey stick.

The Canadian court issued it’s final ruling in favor of the Dismissal motion that was filed in May 2019 by Dr Tim Ball’s libel lawyers.

Not only did the court grant Ball’s application for dismissal of the nine-year, multi-million dollar lawsuit, it also took the additional step of awarding full legal costs to Ball. A detailed public statement from the world-renowned skeptical climatologist is expected in due course.

This extraordinary outcome is expected to trigger severe legal repercussions for Dr Mann in the U.S. and may prove fatal to climate science claims that modern temperatures are “unprecedented.” […]

Dr Mann lost his case because he refused to show in open court his R2 regression numbers (the ‘working out’) behind the world-famous ‘hockey stick’ graph (shown above).

Real science, not the phony “consensus” version, requires open access to data, so that skeptics (who play a key role in science) can see if results are reproducible. Of course, there are no falsifiable experimental data associated with the global warming predictions of doom, so it doesn’t really stand as science as Karl Popper defined it.

This is an important victory in the process of debunking the warmist scare.

August 27, 2019 - Posted by | Deception, Science and Pseudo-Science |


  1. It is hard to believe that a scientific result of such importance was never reviewed. The whole scam was relied upon without anyone even checking the numbers for 20+ years. Does this mean that ever PHD and grad student was stupid/incompetent or too afraid to ask “where is the data behind the graph”. I’ll put my 25 cents on stupid.

    Comment by GGH | August 27, 2019 | Reply

  2. Stop it. Hockey stick is a crock.

    Comment by tsisageya | August 27, 2019 | Reply

  3. Loses lawsuit. Boo hoo hoo.

    Comment by tsisageya | August 27, 2019 | Reply

  4. HOWEVER, humans are devastating the planet because of greed. Climate change has nothing to do with it.

    Comment by tsisageya | August 27, 2019 | Reply

    • In fact there is no such thing as climate change.

      Comment by tsisageya | August 27, 2019 | Reply

      • Let that be a clue. For example, the reason the salmon run is so disappointing this year isn’t because of CLIMATE CHANGE. It’s because of over-fishing by HUMANS/GREED, and habitat destruction. You fools.

        Comment by tsisageya | August 27, 2019 | Reply

  5. Humans had a glorious Earth to enjoy, but they ruined it, and they still double down on the ruination and CONTINUE ruining.
    What a shame.

    Comment by tsisageya | August 27, 2019 | Reply

    • …well, at least our lying overlords continue to ruin. Us poors aren’t like that at all. They must live in an evil bubble. That’s the only thing I can reckon.

      Comment by tsisageya | August 27, 2019 | Reply

  6. Who are ‘they’, you ask. Well, I think you all already know where I’m coming from without my even saying. Filter out the noise.

    Comment by tsisageya | August 27, 2019 | Reply

  7. Us Goyim are nothing but cattle. THE UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT is nothing but cattle.

    Comment by tsisageya | August 27, 2019 | Reply

    • They’re not very delicious though. In fact, they’re disgusting. In fact, the corruption of my own government is disgusting. I vomit.

      And the media. I hate you. I’ve hated you since Peter Jennings. Liars.

      Comment by tsisageya | August 27, 2019 | Reply

  8. I hate liars. I hate traitors. I hate corruption. I hate that I’ve been lied to my entire life and that I don’t even know how to teach by babies. I hate you.

    Comment by tsisageya | August 27, 2019 | Reply

  9. I think all you filthy men/women should be buried in the desert with honey poured over your head. Then, fire ants.
    I hear tell that, for the worst offenses in the Native American world, they let the women decide the punishing. Let me be there too.

    Comment by tsisageya | August 27, 2019 | Reply

  10. But the Good Book teaches that vengeance belongs to the Lord. I will go with that.

    Comment by tsisageya | August 27, 2019 | Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.