Aletho News


Replacing Natural Gas With Hydrogen Is A Fairy Tale

Hydrogen as an energy source for powering transport and heating poses colossal technical and cost challenges

No Tricks Zone | October 15, 2022

By Die kalte Sonne 

Article at Telepolis (Heise).

A mostly ignored problem in the hydrogen discussion is that the existing gas grids are not suitable for handling larger amounts of hydrogen. Thus, the Scientific Advisory to the German Bundestag had already dealt with the issue in the past. It came to the conclusion that “unlimited quantities of methane” could be fed into the gas networks. But concluded

For hydrogen produced by means of electrolysis, the limits are currently 1-10 percent by volume.”

Indeed, a problem generally known in materials research is that hydrogen leads to the embrittlement of metals. Many of the pipeline steels currently in use react to contact with hydrogen by significantly reducing elongation at break and becoming hydrogen brittle.”

The article is also critical of heating with hydrogen:

Using hydrogen to heat homes is, by comparison, less economical, less efficient, more resource-intensive and also has a greater environmental impact, Rosenow argues.

But the alternative is not as ‘green’ as hydrogen likes to be called. Among other things, it is pointed out that considerable technical changes would also be required in households, including the piping in the home, among other things due to embrittlement. This would also cost households an enormous amount of money.

In addition, it is abundantly inefficient to use electricity from renewable sources to electrolyze water to produce hydrogen for this purpose. ‘In the UK, heating homes with green hydrogen would use about six times more renewable electricity than heat pumps,’ David Cebon of the Hydrogen Science Coalition and professor of mechanical engineering at Cambridge University tells the BBC.

There is neither the time nor the resources to investigate further the role of hydrogen in heating homes, especially if the laws of thermodynamics are respected, he added.”

October 16, 2022 - Posted by | Timeless or most popular


  1. Noted. Who’s in charge?


    Comment by roberthstiver | October 17, 2022 | Reply

  2. There may be problems with Hydrogen in the gas supply. But there were problems with Natural Gas when we switched from ‘Towns’ gas, which also led to costly modifications to end-user equipment. Those were overcome and the costs dissipated. Also, there were environmental benefits of not burning coal in towns. And obvious benefits in using a natural resource that was leaking to atmosphere anyway. Hydrogen from renewable electricity is not so “inefficient” when produced during high wind-speeds and low demand, or from wave and tidal power which are currently largely unused. Resistance to change is often due to vested interests.

    Liked by 1 person

    Comment by jbthring | October 17, 2022 | Reply

    • My layman eyes and mind appreciate your comment!…perhaps esp. your “wave and tidal power….”

      Liked by 1 person

      Comment by roberthstiver | October 17, 2022 | Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: