Aletho News


Hate to Say It, but We Told You So!

Dave Lindorff | This Can’t Be Happening | 03 – 16 – 2011

It seems rather silly now, doesn’t it, all the US concern about terrorism?

The nuclear crisis in Japan, which continues to worsen, threatens to become a total multiple meltdown, combined with the perhaps even more disastrous explosion and fire in one or several spent fuel rod ponds. If any of these things happen, not to mention many of them, several hundred square miles of Japan would be rendered indefinitely uninhabitable, costing hundreds of billions of dollars. And it could be worse. If the winds are blowing south during such a disaster, all of Tokyo, which has a metropolitan population of over 30 million, could have to be evacuated.

A study by the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission back in 1997, found that one spent fuel disaster could devastate almost 200 square miles of the US, and cause half a trillion dollars in damage!

And we’re spending hundreds of billions of dollars a year chasing after a few thousand ragtag Taliban fighters and supposedly pursuing a few hundred Arab terrorists, most of whom are fighting back with their shoes and their underwear?

So where is the real risk to America’s security?

Well, for starters, we could consider the 23 nuclear plants currently operating in the US that were built by General Electric using the same basic flawed design as those that are blowing up in Fukushima, Japan right now. Those plants, which are located in my state of Pennsylvania, as well as everywhere from Alabama to Nebraska and Vermont, are as much as 40 years old. They are only still in operation today because the NRC is such an industry-captive regulator that it has granted them long license extensions running way past their sell-by date. It has even given many of them the okay to run at capacities exceeding 100% of design standards!

There are other plants, also creaky with age, such as the ones in San Onofre and Diablo Canyon, California, which were knowingly built within a few miles of major earthquake faults–faults which could produce earthquakes on a scale of the one that just hit Japan. Both those facilities were designed to allegedly be able to survive (when new) a 7.5 quake. That was an untestable assertion of faith, but in any case, with an 8, an 8.5 or a 9, all bets would be off.

San Onofre, by the way, is closer to Los Angeles than Fukushima is to Tokyo, so if there is a threat now that Tokyo might have to be evacuated, a similar blowup of the San Onofre nuke reactor would have the millions of people in Los Angeles evacuating their city–maybe back to Oklahoma where their forebears fled from the Dust Bowl (maybe we could call them LAkies, though hopefully they’d get a friendlier reception than L.A. gave to the okies of yore).

So much for America’s only remaining export: the film industry.

It would make far more sense for the US to forget about those alleged terrorists who are supposedly out to get us (and to stop mucking around in the Middle East countries and provoking all that anger!) and instead to spend some of that Pentagon and Homeland Security swill to shut down these old nuke plants, and even many newer ones that are built in vulnerable locations, so we don’t have to suffer a disaster of our own making like the people of Japan are facing today.

Don’t expect much from our two nuke-besotted political parties, though.

Senate Minority leader Mitch McConnell, a man of stunningly limited intellectual ability who gives the impression when he talks of having just sucked on a lemon, weighed in with a defense of current government plans to subsidize and build more nuclear power plants in the US, saying that “right after a major environmental catastrophe” would “not be a very good time to be making American domestic policy.”

President Obama, is also backing a so-called “nuclear renaissance” in the US. A senior White House source has reportedly said that the president remains in favor of nuclear power and that U.S. nuclear plants were made to survive strong storms and earthquakes. And on Tuesday, as Japan pulled workers out of the Fukushima plant, essentially giving up the fight to prevent disaster because of the level of radioactivity there, the president told local Pittsburgh TV station KDKA that he had been assured that US reactors were safe (sic), closely monitored (sic), and designed to withstand earthquakes and other natural disasters (sic).

Of course, as Mother Jones magazine has noted, this same president, back in 2009, was touting the safety of Japanese nuclear plants as a model for the US. Back then, at a “town meeting” event, he said, “There’s no reason why, technologically, we can’t employ nuclear energy in a safe and effective way. Japan does it and France does it, and it doesn’t have greenhouse gas emissions, so it would be stupid for us not to do that in a much more effective way.”

Now, I admit it’s like shooting fish in a barrel to respond to these two shills for the nuclear industry, but what the hell, I’m going to fire anyhow.

Mr. McConnell, if now, when the folly of nuclear power is on full display in Japan, is not the time to discuss a plan to expand the use of nuclear power in the US, when exactly would be the right time?

And Mr. Obama, would you care to rephrase that 2009 line of yours in light of recent events? Perhaps it might be better to say, “Japan has shown what can happen with nuclear power when something goes wrong, so it would be stupid for us to continue to do here what they have done” and build nuclear plants all over the country on fault lines, near oceans and rivers, and near populations centers.

Watching all this go down is terribly frustrating. As my wife Joyce said yesterday morning, when we awoke to read of the looming threat of a full meltdown of perhaps as many as three or four reactors and the burning of one or more spent fuel piles in Japan, “We were right all along when we opposed nuclear power back in the 1970s.”

Yes we were. Shouldn’t all us anti-nukers now get some street cred, some media respect, and some respect from the political class for our prescience?

Nah. Don’t expect it. Money talks, and the nuclear establishment [and military industrial complex] has the power–even if it is blowing up on them.

March 16, 2011 - Posted by | Militarism, Nuclear Power


  1. Well… it has ALWAYS seemed ridiculous, if one looks at the known history, without relying on what supposedly happened before any of us were born. The twin terrors, amerika and britain own most of the world, or at least occupy it. Watching the Freedom fighters ongoing struggle for the right to a LIFE, in the Middle East, we can see how amerikas power/MONEY, reaches far and wide, covertly or overtly, to quench those who want equal rights as we were given by God to enjoy. However, there is no freedom on earth, much as some would believe otherwise. There never has been. We live our lives as the ‘rulers’ have decreed that we will live it. Bullies run our lives, as bullies run the lives of many families, many workplaces, all over the world. When one rises up to question authority, they are stomped on, hated and despised by both sides… but that is the world.

    If we really want to look at how simple our lives could be, we would have to look at how it really is. There are [at the moment] 195 countries in the world. At the beginning of WWI Britain owned 1/3 of the world. They still own 35 countries. amerika has militery bases in over 135 countries. The statistics change as these two coutries dictate. Not much room for freedom, when these guys are at the helm of what goes down. Look at Gaza.. who in the hell dictates WHY these Gazans are held captive, murdered at will, starved, no water rights, homes being blown to bits, over and over, WHO stands up to these bullies???? IRAN! And they are blasted by media at every turn..called terrorists BY THE REAL terrorists… but even Iran hasn’t yet stopped the tyranny… but let’s go back to the topic of nuclear energy. If we really want to get down to the simple problem of energy, we can look at the inventers of those who KNEW energy is free for the taking in our Universe.. it is a gift from God. Man has stolen it. They charge a fortune for it.. when we KNOW how to harness it for free. Ok.. the problem of gas.. we know how to make cars run on water. For free.. again stifled by the evil rulers of this world. Health.. sickness is invented by the rulers of this world, but if it wasn’t and by some chance someone DID get ill, quantum physics/more free energies, frequencies can heal them FOR FREE…. so.. what is the problem? GREED and power. It has poisoned their brains, they can think of NOTHING but MORE of what they already own.. 99% of ALL the wealth of the earth.. less than 1% own it all. They have poisoned the air we breath, the food we eat, the water we drink. It is ALL poisoned. The evilness that rules this world.. and they will continue to exploit mankind until someone puts a stop to it. The only one who can do that is the Creator of it all. The ONE they say does not exist… oh but He does….Personally I can’t wait..


    Comment by Joyce | March 16, 2011

  2. Dear Dave,

    I’m 56 years old and grew up 11 miles from Three Mile Island in Lancaster County, PA.

    On the first Earth Day in 1971, I made a film to show for it of TMI and it’s terrible effects on nature. In the seperate sound recording I consistently repeated how this place was going to kill people. Of course, no one seemed to take it seriously. I was 16 years old.

    Eight years later and over 200 miles west, when the TMI accident occurred, it killed my twin sons and I sat horrified in a Pittsburgh hospital for 28 days watching hundreds of women lose their babies. Thank God for Jay M. Gould and Benjamin A. Goldman who wrote “Deadly Deceit: Low Level Radiation, High Level Cover-up.

    I thank you for your ongoing efforts to speak up and let me give you my personal STREET CRED and RESPECT and tell you Thank you! And best of all, I have spent the last 40 years researching a viable alternative that will completely replace oil, gas, coal, and nuclear power!

    My fiance’ and i have efforting to finance a $200 – $300 million project get the scientists to finish their project and to introduce this technology to a public market.

    We are elated to report it is in the works and will soon be on our web page and be publically available in two years.

    It’s very late here in the Colorado Mountains, so please forgive the shortened version.

    Please feel free to write to us, we are starting up a “popular movement” with only positive things said and done by us. Of course, some truths aren’t always “positive” but we are intending to re-invent HOPE and share it all around.

    Loss and suffering teach many good lessons.

    John Herr
    (970) 903-6273 call anytime


    Comment by John Herr Executive Director of Imagining Solutions 501 C-3 | March 18, 2011

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.