Aletho News


The Kurdish project in Syria would be a new Israel in the Middle East

By Eva Bartlett | RT | December 2, 2021

Syrians accuse the Western-backed Kurdish enclave in the country of using ethnic cleansing and child soldiers against them to form a new anti-Arab state. The parallels with Israel’s creation in the 1940s are striking.

Kurdish forces in Syria have been lauded by many in the West as being fighters for freedom and an autonomous society. But, unless you’ve been following independent researchers and the Syrian media, you might be unaware of the crimes the US-backed group have been committing over a number of years.

On November 25, the Daily Sabah (a website not sympathetic to the Syrian government) reported on one of their most sickening practices. It revealed, “YPG/PKK terrorists detained three more 15-year-old girls – Hediyye Abdurrahim Anter, Evin Jalal Halil and Ayana Idris Ibrahim – in Amuda in Hassakeh province on Nov. 21 to forcibly recruit them as ‘child fighters.’ The terror group detained two children, aged 13 and 16, in early August. And two children aged 16 and 13 were kidnapped Aug. 23.”

The piece went on to note that this practice of abducting children and forcing them to fight has been documented by the United Nations, with one report stating that the YPG/PKK used more than 400 children between July 2018 and June 2020.

Yet, the world has been led to believe that the self-declared autonomous region – known as Rojava and comprising areas of Hassakeh, Raqqa, Deir ez-Zor and Aleppo governorates – is a haven for liberals and feminists, with freedom-loving Kurdish fighters based there fighting ISIS and liberating Syria.

Indeed, the YPG Rojava page claims: “The YPG was set up to protect the legacy and values of the people of Rojava and is founded on the principles of the paradigm of a democratic society, ecology and woman’s liberation. Without preferring or discriminating any religion, language, nation, gender or political parties, the YPG is protecting the country against all attacks from outside. The YPG is the Democratic Nation’s defense force and is not related to any political party.”

It reads like a feelgood fairytale, but is not based in reality.

The utopian image of the so-called Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF), which includes the YPG and PKK, is betrayed by the kidnappings, which sadly are not a new development. Search for QSD – their Arabic acronym – on Syrian media and you’ll see regular updates on Kurdish forces kidnapping civilians and journalists.

This image is further betrayed by their ethnic cleansing of indigenous Syrians from the northeastern Syrian regions Kurdish forces occupy and collaboration with illegally occupying US forces.

But this won’t be highlighted in corporate media. Instead, you will still find odes romanticizing Kurdish fighters, with one such recent story deceptively saying that the areas controlled by Kurdish forces have a “predominantly Kurdish population” – a claim not backed up by the truth.

As author Stephen Gowans detailed in a 2017 article, Kurds in Syria comprise, “only a small percentage of the Syrian population… Estimates of the proportion of the total Kurd population living in Syria vary from two to seven percent based on population figures presented in the CIA World Factbook.”

And yet, Assyrians, Arameans, and other Syrians who have lived there for generations should accept being ruled, or expelled, by Kurds?

Gowans went on to note, “Kurdish fighters have used the campaign against ISIS as an opportunity to extend Kurdistan into traditionally Arab territories in which Kurds have never been in the majority.”

In 2018, Syrian journalist Sarah Abed wrote of the SDF’s kidnapping and ethnic cleansing, noting not only the abductions of men, but, again, children. She recorded how Eddie Gaboro Hanna, the founder of Patriarchal Relief Care Australia, a group providing assistance to Christian families impacted by wars in Syria and Iraq, had explained, “They are taking young Christian boys by force to sign them up for the Kurdish military and send them to the front line.”

And he added, “Christians are treated as second-class citizens [here] in their own land. Just like how ISIS has the Islamic tax they have their own Kurdish one. They’ve replaced ISIS.”

Although the BBC’s coverage of the Kurds’ activities in Syria is predictably pro-SDF, in 2015, even it reported on their ethnic cleansing and displacing of indigenous Syrians. Citing an Amnesty International report, it noted the YPG were accused of “razing entire villages after capturing them from Islamic State (IS),” in Hassakeh and Raqqa provinces.

The Kurds’ history in Syria

In January 2019, I spoke with geopolitical analyst and Sputnik contributor Laith Marouf about the Kurds in Syria. A descendant of eastern Syria’s Deir ez-Zor governorate, part of which is now occupied by Kurds, Marouf had a lot to say about the history of the Kurds in Syria and this 21st century land-usurpation project.

He told me, “There was a wave of Kurdish refugees coming down to Syria (from Turkey) in the 1940s, and the second wave of them in the 1960s when the PKK started the armed rebellion against the Turkish government in what was Arab lands.”

“They were given citizenship by the Syrian government. They were armed and given protection by the Syrian state to fight for their liberation in the Kurdistan mountains in Turkey, and the Syrian government housed the leadership of all the Kurdish resistance up until the early 90s.”

Marouf noted that Syria’s support for the Kurds saw Turkey threatening to invade in the 1990s and building numerous dams on the Euphrates, cutting the water flow. Yet, Syria refused to hand over PKK leader Abdullah Öcalan. Marouf emphasized: “Syria almost went to war with Turkey, and the Syrian people (in the northeast) went thirsty and the agricultural fields—the breadbasket of Syria—almost collapsed those couple of years, to protect Kurdish rights.”

“And then what happens now is some crazies are saying there’s something called Rojava and that they can secede and colonize and settle and steal parts of Syrian lands.”

He, too, spoke of the years of kidnappings and disappearances of those critical of Kurdish rule. “Even Kurdish Syrians that are critical of what the YPG is doing, even remotely critical professors in the universities in Hassakeh and Raqqa and Deir ez-Zor, were disappeared. And these were just critical Kurds.

“So you could imagine what happened to the Assyrian and the Arab leaders in the area, thinkers, tribal leaders, ex-military – huge amounts of disappearances and forced displacements.”

And as Abed’s article highlighted, formerly Assyrian villages in Hassakeh and Raqqa have been fully taken over by Kurdish forces. “They’re moving in the Kurdish militias and their family members into those villages and creating new ethnically pure towns and villages that are Kurdish. And this is expanding to the holdings of the Syrian churches and their Armenian churches, they confiscated all their land.”

So much, then, for the Rojava “legacy and values” that included “without preferring or discriminating any religion, language, nation, gender or political parties.”

Marouf also said, “They have enforced an educational curriculum on all the schools—including schools that are run by ethnic and/or religious groups – so all those that are run by the churches are being told that they have to teach a certain curriculum that specifically promotes and propagates falsehoods about the Kurdish control of the area.”

“When the Assyrians refused, because these are their own private schools that are controlled by the church, the YPG went ahead and shut down all the schools, with armed men making sure the kids cannot go to school.”

The ethnic cleansing and forced expulsion of indigenous people sounds horribly familiar, as Marouf pointed out. “So, the reality is that we have an ethno-nationalist settler colonial state being enforced by the empire, called Rojava – and it’s being sold the exact way that Israel was being sold in the 1940s. It’s like cut and paste propaganda saying that we’re creating a utopia of secular and socialist government in the ‘sea of barbaric Arabs.’”

Over the years, I’ve had Rojava supporters criticize me for respecting Syria’s sovereignty and speaking critically about the West’s attempt to overthrow the Syrian government. Instead, according to them, I should have been supporting this false utopia which has killed and displaced many. To them, I say you have been deluded, as much of the Western left has on Syria.

And you can rest assured that had it been Syria committing these crimes, the media would be reporting loudly and regularly. But because they are being carried out by puppets of the West, all is quiet on that front.

Eva Bartlett is a Canadian independent journalist and activist. She has spent years on the ground covering conflict zones in the Middle East, especially in Syria and Palestine (where she lived for nearly four years).

December 2, 2021 - Posted by | Ethnic Cleansing, Racism, Zionism | , , ,


  1. Aletho: I was writing on this topic back in 2015. At my now shut down blog. I brought forth the November 27 2015 post to my new site

    That was literally one of dozens written long before Bartlett saw the light. Was one of the reasons I often contradicted some of the ‘information’ you had posted here.


    Comment by penny2 | December 2, 2021 | Reply

  2. Aletho, I wrote about this going back years ago at my google blog, now taken down.
    In fact in light of Ms Bartlett ‘seeing the light, finally’ I went and dug up the 2015 post.. via the wayback machine
    reposted at my own site

    Many have been missing the bigger picture for years and years- Ms Bartlett’s article isn’t anything startling or new. It’s way behind the times to some of us


    Comment by Penny | December 2, 2021 | Reply

    • You may be congratulated for spotting this arm of Eretz Israel early on. But it was given impetus way back in 1982 when Oded Yinon’s Hebrew paper ‘A Strategy for Israel in the 1980’s’ was translated and published by the brave Prof. Israel Shahak, inwhich the malicious strategy of infiltrating neighbouring states and aiding malcontents to over-throw governments inorder to dissolve the Arab states. Even that plot was not new but hatched by Zionists in Germany from in1890 to 1933. What Eva Bartlett brings to the world’s attention is this use of murderous YPG Kurds to bring about Yinon’s strategy against poor devastated Syria. The fact that they were helped by the Syrian government against Turkey is an astounding feat of Zionist mendacity, helped, no doubt, by its planting of anti-Assad and pro-Kurdish propaganda in the western media to fool the US neo-Cons into supporting the heist. Hopefully, one day these plots and atrocities will be exposed when the orchestrated media is under a new conductor.


      Comment by jbthring | December 3, 2021 | Reply

      • As stated Ms Bartlett’s news doesn’t bring anything new to the table- It’s long been obvious the murderous kurds YPG/PKK have been deeply, deeply involved in this strategy to bring about the Yinon plan. We can even talk about their role going back to Afghanistan rebels and the destruction of Iraq.

        The fact that they, kurds, were helped by the Syrian government against Turkey? When? What time period are we talking about?
        Since the destabilization of Syria began circa 2011?
        Many years prior to that when Syria protected Ocalan? Which saw the two nations nearly at war with one another? Turkey and Syria being the two nations I’m referencing. Which then resulted in the Adana Agreement/Accord being agreed to?

        Liked by 1 person

        Comment by Penny | December 3, 2021 | Reply

  3. Whether dupes or agents, the anarchist left committed an astounding betrayal in supporting the “Rojava” brand. From Murray Bookchin to Noam Chomsky to Democracy Now to Bookchin’s daughter to SubMedia, the left has lent abject support to US and Israeli efforts to destroy Syria.

    Not surprisingly the same left supports worldwide fascism by approving the Gates, Schwab, Fauci “Covid” narrative.

    Liked by 1 person

    Comment by Richard | December 2, 2021 | Reply

    • The self described left has gone off it’s collective rocker as of late.
      It’s not a surprise that Bookchin or Chomsky would support this plot. They are diie hard Israel firsters/ zionists at heart.

      Most people are completely unaware that way to many Kurds are hard line sunni muslims- Which is why the have good relations with Israel, Saudi Arabia and the US/UK


      Comment by Penny | December 3, 2021 | Reply

    • The left has lost it’s way. On so many issues.
      As for Bookchin and Chomsky- what else could be expected from ardent Israel firsters?

      Liked by 1 person

      Comment by Penny | December 3, 2021 | Reply

    • It’s more akin to worldwide Communism than Fascism, but, It’s still tyranny!


      Comment by papasha408 | December 3, 2021 | Reply

  4. Oh, yes, that is all the world needs! A new parasite that whines incessantly!


    Comment by papasha408 | December 2, 2021 | Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.